Skip to main content

How to Write a Book Review

After several readers mentioned barriers to leaving reviews, I decided to nix the grammar post I had planned for today and post a book review how-to instead. It's very easy. I promise.
First, make sure you are logged onto the website in question (Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Goodreads, etc.).

Let's start with Amazon.

Go to the book's retail page.

If this is the correct book, scroll down to the review section and click the 'write a customer review' button.

A screen will open that looks like this.

First, click the blank stars to assign a rating. You can click different ones until the number of stars you want turn yellow. (Clicking the one on the far right assigns 5 stars.)

Next, give your review a headline. I usually add a short statement that sums up my overall thoughts or highlights a certain aspect that stood out to me. Ex: Fast-paced romance or Heart wrenching and wonderful!

If you can't think of a headline, never fear. You can leave it blank.

Next, type your comments in the 'write your review' box. You can delete and retype as many times as you like.

What do you write? Easy - just focus on the things you liked about the story.

This was such a good book! It kept my attention the whole way through. Or... I really loved how the author made me feel what the characters were feeling. Or... The plot had lots of twists and turns. It really kept me guessing!

What if there was something you didn't like about it? You can say nothing, you can include a negative comment, or you can turn the negative into a positive.

The book was long and really dragged in places could be exchanged for: If you like books with a slower pace that are long enough to sink into, this one's for you.

When it comes to specific content, such as violence or sex, don't be afraid to include a comment, even if it's negative. This helps prospective buyers decide if the book is for them. You might've not liked the level of violence, but there are plenty of readers who do and who will buy the book because you mentioned it.

What NOT to write...

It isn't necessary to write a synopsis of the story. That information is already posted on the retail page.

Don't leave seller feedback. (If your book never arrived or came damaged, there's a place in the 'my orders' section of your Amazon account to deal with that.) The review section is for readers to post their thoughts about the story.

And please don't include spoilers! If you do, type a warning first.

When you're satisfied with what you've typed, click the button that says 'submit.'

Viola! You're done!

If you realize you made a mistake, no problem. Just go to the review once it appears on the site and click edit. Make sure to save your changes.

Before you click away from the website, consider following the author, so you'll be notified of new releases. To do this, click on the author's name under the title of the book (retail page) and go to his/her author page, then click the  'follow' button.

Of note...
Readers tell me you have to spend at least $50 per year on the Amazon site to be allowed to leave reviews. (I wouldn't know. My e-book purchases, alone, more than meet that requirement. LOL)

What about other sites?

On Barnes & Noble, it's basically the same. Log in, go the to book's retail page, and scroll down to the review section.

Goodreads isn't a retail site, but it's still helpful to rate and review books there. You can even mark a book 'want to read' before you read it.

The drop-down box gives you other choices, such as 'read' or 'currently reading,' and clicking on the stars will rate it and open up the review screen.

Another place to follow authors and get notified of free books and sales is BookBub.

Some final things to consider...

Amazon reviews are the most coveted, but authors will be grateful no matter where you leave a review. And you'll have our eternal affection if you leave reviews on more than one site.

You can leave a review anywhere, no matter where (or if) you bought the book. The only ethical requirement is that you read it.

Your review doesn't have to be long or complicated. Just type a sentence or two that tell what you liked about the book. Even something short like 'Great book!' or 'Couldn't put it down!' is fine.

You don't have to give it 5 stars. Though most authors prefer at least 3, any review is better than no review.

If your goal is to support the author, then focus your comments on the things you liked about the story, even if you don't give it 5 stars.

There can never be too many reviews. Whether a book has 5 reviews or 500, leave one, too. This helps an author's rank and keeps the book more visible to new customers.

If you enjoy reading and reviewing stories (especially if you're on a limited budget), you might consider joining your favorite author's review team. You'll get free e-books to read, and the author gets your support in the form of reviews. To find out if this is possible for the author in question, simply reach out to him or her and ask (most authors have a contact form on their blog or website). We love to hear from readers!

Tell people about the book and ask your local library to carry it. You can also post about it if you blog.

Thanks for taking the time to read this. 
Reviewing books is easy once you know how to get started.


  1. Thanks so much Melissa for posting about this today. Such good information to have!

  2. I give this review process a 5 star review! :)

  3. I feel the reviewer's pain. I can write whole novels, but sometimes have the hardest time coming up with a few helpful words. I think I try to hard to make it I know how much it means to the writer, so that just locks up my brain.

    1. It is different when you know the author, for sure.

  4. I'm really bad about leaving reviews, even for books I loved by authors who could use the reviews. I always feel like I should write long ones, but they take so much time to write I keep putting it off. I need to get better at leaving short reviews. Thanks for the hints.

    1. I know. Lately, I've been that way, too. Life is just so busy.

      That said, Amazon makes it easy. If you go to 'your orders,' you can go down the list and leave reviews for all the books you've bought lately. (This, of course, assumes you bought them there.) Making notes in your e-reader while you're reading also helps to gather your thoughts later.

  5. Thank you for posting about this important element. Reviews are more important than most readers realize and difficult to come by. I'm grateful for every one of mine.

  6. Love this post! Yes, Amazon is insisting that $50 are spent each year before a review is frustrating. But there are so many places to leave reviews. Even a 2 or 3 word one is better than none :)

    1. I wish, for book reviews at least, they would lower that requirement to only purchasing the book in question.

  7. I try to leave reviews on Goodreads, although I am behind.

  8. I try and write reviews, but not sure they are particularly helpful.

  9. I'd heard that Amazon requires you to have purchased the book from them before letting someone leave a review for a book.

    1. I don't think so, unless it's a new thing. They do put a tag 'Verified purchase' next to the reviews written by customers who bought the book from Amazon.

  10. Great tips. And so timely. I'm realizing that I need to start leaving short reviews of the books I read.

    1. Me, too. I've been bad about leaving them lately.

  11. These are all great tips. Thank you. And yes, a short one sentence review is better than none at all.

  12. That $50 explains why I couldn't leave a review on Amazon US last time. Pretty frustrating. I need to be better at leaving reviews because I'm not very consistent. I'm also bad at writing them for very successful books with many reviews, although I usually put a rating on Goodreads at least. I prefer to use my time to support the "underdogs" with only a few reviews, but you're right that every good read deserves a write-up.

    1. I wish amazon would change the policy, at least where books are concerned.

      Regarding books with a lot of reviews, I tend to do the same and for some of the same reasons as you. Guilty. LOL

  13. This is a great post. As much as we ask for reviews, so many readers have no clue how to do it. Thank you!

    1. You're welcome. I'm glad you found it helpful. :)

  14. Really interesting post - because while I know it's important to leave a review - it's good to hear some of the "back story" from an author's POV!

  15. Those last bullet points are perfect.

  16. Cool stuff you have got and you keep update all of us. how to remove fake reviews


Post a Comment

I love to hear what you have to say.
Thanks for taking the time to comment. = )